CURRENT MENU
All items are available in the shop on a first come, first served basis.
Pre-orders may be placed online by visiting our Online Shop.
Have questions? Please email hello@sisterpie.com.
UPDATED 3/27/2025
Note from the SP team: Starting 2/24, the price of our pies has increased in response to the rising cost of eggs. Hopefully, this will be a temporary change and we can re-adjust the prices in the future. As always, thank you for your support and understanding.
MARCH MENU
ENDS 3/30/2025
PIES
9" Salted Maple
$40.00 whole pie / $5.32 slice
9" The Banana Pete
$47.00 whole pie / $6.20 slice
9" Milk Chocolate Chess
$39.00 whole pie / $5.20 slice
9" Malted Lime
$52.00 whole pie / $6.82
available Fridays, Saturdays, Sundays
refrigerated pie
EASTER SPECIALS
available Friday 4/18 - Sunday 4/20
pre-orders open at 10:00am Friday 4/4
9" Salted Maple
$40.00 whole pie / $5.32 slice
9" Malted Lime
$52.00 whole pie / $6.82 slice
refrigerated pie
9" Milk Chocolate Chess
$39.00 whole pie / $5.20 slice
9" Ricotta Rice Pudding
$42.00 whole pie / $5.25 slice
refrigerated pie
9" Sweet Carrot
$42.00 whole pie / $5.58 slice
6" Malted Lime
$23.92 whole pie
refrigerated pie
6" Milk Chocolate Chess
$17.94 whole pie
6" Sweet Carrot
$19.32 whole pie
Hot Cross Buns
$3.50 each / $21.00 half-dozen
Hot cross buns are said to be medicinal, and there's plenty of history and tradition to go along with that, but the real reason we make them is simply because they're delicious. Our are made with a sweet dough full of booze-soaked dried fruit, citrus zest, and warm spices, topped with a citrus icing.
PASSOVER SPECIAL
available Saturday 4/12 + Sunday 4/13
pre-orders open at 10:00am Friday 3/28
9" Bittersweet Chocolate Chess
$30.00 whole pie
This Passover, we are excited to offer a pie made especially for your Seder table. Inspired by coconut macaroons and flourless chocolate cake, we pour a rich bittersweet chocolate filling into a gluten-free coconut macaroon crust to create a pie that is texturallyy pleasing and fairly decadent!
APRIL MENU
STARTS 3/31/2025
PIES
9" Salted Maple
$40.00 whole pie / $5.32 slice
9" Malted Lime
$52.00 whole pie / $6.82 slice
refrigerated pie
9" Coffee Chess
$40.00 whole pie / $5.32 slice
9" Sweet Potato Marshmallow
$42.00 whole pie / $5.25 slice
available Friday, Saturday, Sunday
6" Salted Maple
$18.40 whole pie
available Friday, Saturday, Sunday
6" Chocolate Coconut
$19.32 whole pie
available Friday, Saturday, Sunday
LARGE COOKIES
Buckwheat Chocolate Chip *GF
$2.36 each / $13.25 6-pack
Robert Redford
oats, milk chocolate, pretzels, walnuts
$2.80 each / $13.25 6-pack
Peanut Butter Paprika
$13.25 6-pack
Cookie Trio
a mix of Buckwheat Chocolate Chip,
Golden Oatie, and Triple Chocolate cookies
$13.25 6-pack
SMALL COOKIES
Salted Rosemary Shortbread
$0.80 each
Orange Peel Poppy Seed Shortbread
$1.10 each
Ginger Rye Shortbread
$1.10 each
Lemon Drop
$1.45 each
Pie Sandwich Cookie
$2.10 each
EVERYTHING ELSE
From Another Galaxy Brownie
*GF / VEGAN
$3.85 each / $12.00 3-pack
Seasonal Muffin
$4.00 each
Seasonal Scone
sweet / savory
$4.25 each
Seasonal Savory Hand Pie
$4.30 each
Spranola
aka Sister Pie Granola
$14.50 500 gram bags
Egg-on-Top Galette
Saturdays and Sundays only
$7.00 each
Seasonal Bun
Saturdays and Sundays only
$6.00 each