Apple Cheddar Rye Pie Slice
An SP classic, this pie was on the original Thanksgiving menu, and the first reflection of my obsession with alternative crusts. We use organic dark rye flour from our favorite local mill, which speckles the dough in shades of chestnut. along with sharp white cheddar cheese to compliment the sweet-tart flavor of Michigan apples. The combination of fruit and cheese dates back to ancient times, but the specific combination of apples and cheddar is a New England tradition.
Payment
At this time, online pre-orders can only be paid for by credit card.
Gift cards cannot be redeemed on the website. If you'd like to use your gift card, feel free to place your order and then request a refund by emailing hello@sisterpie.com with your order confirmation number. Gift cards can also be redeemed at the bakery Monday-Friday 8am-3pm and Saturday-Sunday 10am-3pm.
Pre-Order Policy
Pre-orders for pick-up MONDAY - FRIDAY must be placed no later than 7:00am EST the day-of. Pre-orders for pick-up SATURDAY - SUNDAY must be placed no later than 2:00pm EST on Fridays.
If a date is not available to select as an option, it means it has sold out for that day.
Pie Care
Please see our Pie Care + Storage page for some basic instructions for taking care of your pie after you leave our shop.